Shop Sign in Cart

Horror & Scary

Category: Party Supplies
All categories Costumes1756 Masks245 Wigs & Hair310 Makeup & Special FX240 Costume Accessories904 Props & Weapons179 Pet Supplies100 Toys19 Decorations508 Party Supplies495
Theme: Horror & Scary
All themes Horror & Scary643 Animals303 Fantasy355 Historical & Decades246 Occupations156 Princess & Royalty184 Pirates89 Sci-Fi91 Sports57
Price
Under $10 $10 – $25 $25 – $50 $50 – $100 $100+
Clear filters
Halloween Plastic Cup - 32 oz. (Pack of 1) - Durable & Reusable - Ideal for Horror Events, Picnics, and Parties
Amscan
Halloween Plastic Cup - 32 oz. (Pack of 1) - Durable & Reusable - Ideal for Horror Events, Picnics, and Parties
$7.49
Black Gothic Plastic Charger - 13" (6 Count) - Durable & Stylish Tableware, Perfect for Themed Events and Home Dining Decor
Amscan
Black Gothic Plastic Charger - 13" (6 Count) - Durable & Stylish Tableware, Perfect for Themed Events and Home Dining Decor
$24.99
Bold Black Decorative Shred (4.2 oz) - Premium Natural Wood Fillers for Gift-Wrap, Crafts & Home Decor - Unique, Eco-Friendly & Eye-Catching Color
Amscan
Bold Black Decorative Shred (4.2 oz) - Premium Natural Wood Fillers for Gift-Wrap, Crafts & Home Decor - Unique, Eco-Friendly & Eye-Catching Color
$11.99
Creepy Carnival Lunch Paper Napkins - 6.5" x 6.5" | Blacklight Reactive | Pack of 40
Amscan
Creepy Carnival Lunch Paper Napkins - 6.5" x 6.5" | Blacklight Reactive | Pack of 40
$10.99
Creepy Eyeball Bounce Balls- 6 pcs.
Amscan
Creepy Eyeball Bounce Balls- 6 pcs.
$5.99
Fun Express Zombie Bash Beverage Napkins
Oriental Trading
Fun Express Zombie Bash Beverage Napkins
$6.98
Light Up Scary Skull Door Candy Bowl Standard
Fun World
Light Up Scary Skull Door Candy Bowl Standard
$17.86
Multicolored Spooky Friends Paper Cups - 9 Oz. (6 Count) | Sturdy Paper Cups, Creepy & Fun Design, Perfect for Halloween Celebrations
Amscan
Multicolored Spooky Friends Paper Cups - 9 Oz. (6 Count) | Sturdy Paper Cups, Creepy & Fun Design, Perfect for Halloween Celebrations
$19.49
Chucky Wanna Play 60 Pack Partyware Disposable Paper Plates, Napkins, and Cups
Silver Buffalo
Chucky Wanna Play 60 Pack Partyware Disposable Paper Plates, Napkins, and Cups
$28.99
Spooktacular Multicolor Cup - 32 oz. (1 Pc.) - Assorted Dazzling Designs, Sturdy Plastic - One-of-a-kind Collectible for Horror Lovers, Disney Tim Burton's Nightmare Before Christmas
Amscan
Spooktacular Multicolor Cup - 32 oz. (1 Pc.) - Assorted Dazzling Designs, Sturdy Plastic - One-of-a-kind Collectible for Horror Lovers, Disney Tim Burton's Nightmare Before Christmas
$9.99
Vampire Halloween 20 Pack 13" Luncheon Napkins Black Gray White Red
Unique
Vampire Halloween 20 Pack 13" Luncheon Napkins Black Gray White Red
$8.99
Vampire Halloween Beverage Napkins, 24ct
Unique
Vampire Halloween Beverage Napkins, 24ct
$13.98
Wicked Hauntings Black Paper Napkins - Spooky Paper Napkins (Pack of 40), Perfect for Haunted Halloween Celebrations & Standout Party Decor
Amscan
Wicked Hauntings Black Paper Napkins - Spooky Paper Napkins (Pack of 40), Perfect for Haunted Halloween Celebrations & Standout Party Decor
$11.99
Wicked Hauntings Black Paper Napkins - Spooky Paper Napkins (Pack of 40), Perfect for Haunted Halloween Celebrations & Standout Party Decor, 5" x 5"
Amscan
Wicked Hauntings Black Paper Napkins - Spooky Paper Napkins (Pack of 40), Perfect for Haunted Halloween Celebrations & Standout Party Decor, 5" x 5"
$10.99
Wicked Hauntings Plastic Horizontal Banner - 33.5" x 65" (1 Count) | Perfect for Spooky Parties, Haunted House Décor & Halloween Fun
Amscan
Wicked Hauntings Plastic Horizontal Banner - 33.5" x 65" (1 Count) | Perfect for Spooky Parties, Haunted House Décor & Halloween Fun
$7.99
Witch's Halloween Trick Or Treat Crew Disposable Beverage Paper Napkins, 5"x 5" Pack of 36.
Amscan
Witch's Halloween Trick Or Treat Crew Disposable Beverage Paper Napkins, 5"x 5" Pack of 36.
$11.99
Witch Themed Paper Party Napkins - 5" x 5" | Assorted Design | Pack of 16
Amscan
Witch Themed Paper Party Napkins - 5" x 5" | Assorted Design | Pack of 16
$9.99